When most travelers think about Amish Country in Pennsylvania, they imagine horse-drawn buggies, homemade quilts, and fresh-baked pies from roadside stands. While those images are true, there’s much more to discover about the authentic Amish lifestyle and culture. If you’re planning a visit to Amish Country, PA, knowing what’s real versus what’s simply staged for tourists will make your trip more meaningful.
This guide explores authentic Amish traditions, food, farms, and experiences in Lancaster County and beyond—helping you connect with the true heart of Amish life.
Understanding Authentic Amish Culture
The Amish community in Pennsylvania is not a tourist attraction—it’s a living, thriving society that has preserved its traditions for over 300 years. The Amish are known for their:
-
Simple living: No modern conveniences like electricity from the grid or cars.
-
Strong faith: Their daily life is centered on religion, family, and community.
-
Handcrafted skills: From quilting and furniture making to farming and baking, Amish craftsmanship is respected worldwide.
When exploring authentic Amish Country in PA, the best way to understand their way of life is by visiting with respect, supporting Amish-owned businesses, and learning from the people themselves rather than staged attractions.
Where to Find Authentic Amish Experiences in Pennsylvania
1. Amish Farms and Roadside Stands
If you’re driving through Lancaster County, you’ll notice small wooden signs at the end of long driveways advertising eggs, produce, quilts, or baked goods. These Amish roadside stands are as authentic as it gets. The pies are made with fresh, local ingredients, and the vegetables often come straight from the family’s garden.
Tip: Carry cash—most Amish families don’t use credit card machines.
2. Amish Markets and Craft Shops
Lancaster Central Market and Bird-in-Hand Farmers Market are popular stops, but the more authentic experiences come from smaller Amish-owned shops tucked away from the main highways. Look for handmade furniture, hand-stitched quilts, and leather goods. Each item tells a story of patience, faith, and family tradition.
3. Horse-and-Buggy Rides
While some buggy rides are commercialized, certain tours are still run by Amish families who share their way of life honestly. Riding through the countryside in a horse-drawn buggy is one of the most authentic experiences in Pennsylvania Amish Country.
4. Amish Restaurants and Family Meals
Restaurants like Good ’N Plenty or family-run dining experiences offer traditional Amish dishes: chicken pot pie (with noodles, not a crust), shoofly pie, chow chow, and whoopie pies. If you get the chance to enjoy a home-cooked Amish meal in Lancaster County, it’s the most genuine way to taste the culture.
Signs You’re Experiencing “Real” Amish Country
Because Amish Country is a major tourist draw, not everything advertised as “Amish” is truly authentic. Here are a few ways to know you’re experiencing the real thing:
-
Handmade, not mass-produced: Authentic Amish crafts and quilts take time and skill. If it looks mass-manufactured, it probably is.
-
No technology use: Amish families won’t have credit card readers or neon “Open” signs. Simplicity is key.
-
Quiet farms, not staged shows: True Amish farms are working farms, not entertainment venues.
-
Respectful interaction: Authentic encounters focus on genuine conversation and cultural exchange, not scripted performances.
Authentic Amish Food You Must Try
The Amish food in Pennsylvania is one of the highlights of any visit. Some authentic dishes include:
-
Shoofly Pie: A molasses-based pie with a crumb topping, famous in Lancaster County.
-
Whoopie Pies: Soft cake-like sandwiches with sweet cream filling.
-
Chicken Pot Pie: A hearty stew with square noodles, not the baked version most people imagine.
-
Homemade Root Beer: Naturally brewed and lightly carbonated, often sold at farm stands.
-
Fresh Bread and Soft Pretzels: Baked in small Amish kitchens with traditional recipes.
How to Respect Amish Culture While Visiting
To truly experience authentic Amish Country, PA, it’s important to be respectful:
-
Don’t take photos of the Amish people. Their beliefs discourage being photographed.
-
Dress modestly and behave politely. Amish culture values humility and simplicity.
-
Support local businesses. Buying directly from Amish farmers, shops, and craftsmen helps preserve their traditions.
-
Drive carefully. Horse-drawn buggies share the road with cars, and safety is important.
Best Towns to Visit for Authentic Amish Country
-
Intercourse, PA: Despite the unusual name, this town is known for Amish shops and farms.
-
Bird-in-Hand: A small town with family-owned restaurants and markets.
-
Strasburg: Famous for its scenic farmland and buggy rides.
-
Paradise: A quiet area with authentic Amish family stands.
-
Lancaster City: While not fully Amish, its markets and history connect directly to Amish culture.
FAQs About Authentic Amish Country, PA
What makes Amish Country in Pennsylvania authentic?
Authenticity comes from experiencing Amish life as it really is—working farms, handmade crafts, family-owned shops, and traditional foods. True Amish experiences in Lancaster County are rooted in simplicity and tradition, not flashy tourist attractions.
Can I visit a real Amish farm?
Yes, many Amish families open their farms for visitors, but it’s important to choose ones that are family-owned rather than staged shows. Look for smaller tours and direct farm stands for a more authentic connection.
What food is authentic in Amish Country, PA?
Authentic foods include shoofly pie, chicken pot pie (with noodles), whoopie pies, chow chow, homemade root beer, and fresh baked bread. These dishes come from Amish kitchens and reflect their traditions.
How do I respect Amish culture while visiting?
Avoid taking photos of Amish people, dress modestly, and interact politely. Supporting Amish-owned shops and driving cautiously around buggies are also ways to show respect.
Are Amish markets authentic?
Some are, especially smaller family-run markets. Larger markets may mix Amish and non-Amish vendors, so authenticity varies. Visiting roadside stands and farm shops ensures your purchases are directly from Amish families.
Final Thoughts
Visiting Amish Country in Pennsylvania is more than just sightseeing—it’s an opportunity to connect with a way of life that values simplicity, family, and tradition. By choosing authentic experiences—buying at roadside stands, enjoying Amish meals, or exploring farms with respect—you’ll walk away with memories that go far beyond the postcards and souvenirs.
The most authentic part of Amish Country, PA isn’t found in staged attractions—it’s in the quiet fields, handmade goods, and the genuine hospitality of the Amish people themselves.